This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Our Edinburgh trip wasn’t in the original plan. Halfway through a week in London, we decided to add a train north, three days in Edinburgh and an early flight home. So I tested AI planners on the hardest job there is: taking a saved trip and changing it mid-trip. This 3 days in Edinburgh itinerary is what we actually did with our 8-year-old, and what seven AI tools did with the same change.

The short version: the replies sounded fine. The saved plans weren’t. Only one tool actually rewrote its calendar, and it linked Edinburgh Castle to a pub. And the most expensive surprise of the whole trip was three centimeters of suitcase.
Best for: families going to Edinburgh by train, with a child, staying outside the city center.
Not for: Edinburgh in festival season. This was late October, Halloween week.
Tested: Edinburgh, October 28 – November 1, 2026. Mid-trip AI test October 25, 2026.
The plot twist: changing plans mid-trip
On October 25, in London, I opened the trips I’d saved in six tools, plus a fresh ChatGPT chat, and asked each one to update the plan. The new plan: Oxford on the 26th, a day trip to Castle Combe on the 27th, the 12:30 LNER train to Edinburgh on the 28th (already booked), a hotel near Edinburgh Park, and a Ryanair flight home at 06:05 on November 1 (also booked). Same English request for all seven.
| Tool | What the reply said | What happened to the saved plan |
|---|---|---|
| Mindtrip | Updated, after one question about the train date | The only calendar that actually changed to Oct 26 – Nov 1. But “Edinburgh Castle” opened a pub called The Ensign Ewart |
| Wanderlog | “Updated your saved plan for October 26–November 1” | The trip dates stayed October 21–26. Edinburgh Castle sat on October 22 |
| Layla | A full new plan, in Russian | The trip card stuck at “Updating trip · 6%”, still showing an old Heathrow flight |
| DimTrip | Started the changes | Stopped with an error after 4 of 9 steps |
| TripBaddie | Finished processing | The same six London days. Still a 19:45 flight from Luton |
| iMean | A new day-by-day plan in the chat | Text only, no calendar |
| ChatGPT (no login) | A full new plan | No saved plan to update: a new chat |
The replies mostly kept the bookings right. Four of seven repeated the train times correctly, and five of seven kept the 06:05 flight. The problem was what you’d see when you opened the app on the day. Two tools said “updated” and weren’t. If you change a trip mid-way, open the saved plan and check the dates yourself.
Some details were just wrong. Mindtrip had us checking out of the London hotel at 12:00 for a 12:30 train from King’s Cross. Wanderlog put the train on October 21, our first day in London. Layla promised an elevator at Camera Obscura.
London to Edinburgh by train
The train. LNER Azuma from King’s Cross, 12:30 to 16:42, stopping at York and Newcastle: 4 hours 12 minutes on the schedule. Our family ticket cost £101.50. We left on time and arrived around 17:00, 15 to 20 minutes late.



Wi-Fi. The LNER network showed up on our phones, but we never managed to connect in four hours. My phone’s 5G did the job.
Our phones worked on our own mobile plans. If yours doesn’t cover the UK, a UK eSIM from Airalo or Yesim is set up before you land.
King’s Cross. The Uber from Wandsworth took 1 hour 2 minutes for about 8 miles, cost £41.95, and dropped us on York Way because of road closures. The stop-and-go traffic made my wife and daughter carsick, and we decided to skip taxis around Edinburgh. The line for the Platform 9¾ photo was long, so we took ours from the side.
If you’re comparing: Lumo runs budget trains on the same line. Its 12:14 to Glasgow showed “Delayed” that day.
Where to stay: Edinburgh Park
We picked a budget hotel near Edinburgh Park, on the west side of the city. It worked for this trip for two reasons: the Gyle Centre tram stop is a five-minute walk, and the airport is close. Getting to Princes Street took about 30 minutes: five minutes on foot and about 24 minutes on the tram, which ran every eight minutes or so.
The first evening was harder. From Waverley we took the Airlink 100 bus (a group ticket for the three of us was £15), then walked about 20 minutes with our suitcases.

If you arrive before check-in or want to sightsee before heading out of the city center, Radical Storage has luggage drop-offs near Waverley station. We went straight to the hotel.
Layla’s mid-trip plan told us to board the tram “right at Waverley” and get off at Edinburgh Park Station. Our stop was Gyle Centre.
Day 1: Old Town, the castle and a mushroom poster
The tram ticket puzzle. A poster in our hotel offered a family 3-day ticket for £25. The tram app only sells day tickets: a family day ticket is £13, so £39 for three days. Later we checked a ticket machine in the city center: no 3-day ticket there either. One machine at our stop was out of service, and a sign warned of a £10 penalty fare. I asked ChatGPT, and it pointed me to the tram website, where the Family 3-Day ticket costs £28. That’s the official price since February 22, 2026, so the hotel poster was out of date. We saved £11. None of the seven AI plans mentioned this ticket.


Princes Street Gardens. The Ross Fountain with the castle above it, a free playground and a churchyard under the rock. The squirrels come almost to your hand for an unshelled peanut, which our daughter loved.

Edinburgh Castle. We hadn’t planned to go in, which was lucky: the sign at the gate said “Sold out today. Pre-booking recommended”. Hours in October to March are 09:30 to 17:00, last entry 16:00. Another sign warned about fake ticket websites. Two of the seven planners said to book ahead (ChatGPT and Mindtrip). None of them warned that it sells out on the day.

Camera Obscura. The entrance was decorated for Halloween and packed. We didn’t go in. If you go with a tired kid, note that the official site says there’s no elevator: 98 steps to the top. Layla’s plan (in Russian) promised “an elevator to the top”.

Lunch on the Royal Mile and dinner at Makars. Fish and chips from the Fish & Frites van: £17.50. Then Makars Gourmet Mash Bar: our booking hadn’t worked, but four doors down the same restaurant has a second room for walk-ins. Beef, lamb, a crumble and three drinks: £63, and the receipt said in capital letters “We DO NOT charge you a service charge”. After a week of 10% to 12.5% added to every bill in London, it was the first one without.
On the wall at Makars there was a poster for tours of the restaurant’s own mushroom farm: £10, one hour, with a grow bag to take home. More on that below.

The locked park. Around 17:20 that evening Google Maps sent us home through Princes Street Gardens. The gates were already closed, and it took a while to find a way out.
Day 2: A slow day
The forecast promised rain for the next day, so we moved the National Gallery to Saturday and kept Friday slow: Cockburn Street and Victoria Street, already hung with Christmas snowflakes, and then The Meadows, with a playground, swings and a zip line, all free.

The hot chocolate with marshmallows from the Uplands Roast kiosk is famous, and the line was about 20 minutes. £5.40 a cup.

We couldn’t get a table at the hot pot place we wanted, so dinner was ramen at Don@Tokyo: £49.80, no service charge.

On the way back we finally saw the sign on the garden gates: “The gardens will close tonight at 17:00.” That explained the night before. iMean’s plan listed Princes Street Gardens as “Always open”. None of the seven tools gave the closing time.

Day 3: Halloween
Waterstones on Princes Street had a free Halloween corner for kids on October 31: coloring, witch hats, tattoo stickers, staff in costumes, and a sign that said “Buy Our Books or DIE”. The café upstairs looks straight at the castle. In the afternoon sun it was too bright for photos.
A picnic in the gardens with food from M&S (£25), the Ferris wheel already standing for Christmas, and the Scott Monument.

The National Gallery on the Mound is free, open 10:00 to 17:00. The lockers take a £2 coin, and two £1 coins won’t work. It’s a donation, so you don’t get it back. Our three coats and a bag fit in one. Van Gogh’s Olive Trees (1889) is there.




The rain never came. Saturday turned out sunny, and at golden hour the castle glowed orange above St Cuthbert’s churchyard.

Halloween in the city meant costumes, decorated bars and the castle lit green and purple at night. At the same time, Edinburgh was already getting ready for Christmas: trees in the Whiski Rooms and the Christmas market going up by the Scott Monument. We didn’t go to any big events. With a 3:45 a.m. pickup, we had an early dinner and went back to the hotel.

Only one of the seven planners mentioned Halloween at all: ChatGPT, which suggested an optional family event and an early evening because of the flight.
What AI missed: hidden gems
After we got home, I asked six AI tools one question, without mentioning the farm: suggest five unusual, hands-on family activities in Edinburgh for late October, with prices and how to book.
None of the six found Makars Mushroom Farm. ChatGPT, Mindtrip, Wanderlog, Layla, iMean and Google AI Mode suggested places like the Chocolatarium, Jupiter Artland, Dynamic Earth and pottery painting studios. iMean recommended Edinburgh Butterfly & Insect World with opening hours and prices, but it closed in 2021.
Dynamic Earth tickets are sold online.
A manual search on GetYourGuide, without AI, found the farm: a 75-minute tour from £15 per person, with a 4.8 rating. It’s not suitable for children under 10, so our 8-year-old couldn’t have gone anyway. I couldn’t find the £10, one-hour version from the restaurant poster.
That’s the honest takeaway: the best local tip came from a poster on a restaurant wall, and it still came with an age limit.
→ Related: AI Hidden Gems Finder: 5 Spots AI Missed — and How to Make It Find Them
The 6:05 a.m. flight
Trams don’t run that early, so we booked an Uber Reserve the evening before: £25.95 for an UberX, including the £8.50 Edinburgh airport fee. The car picked us up at 03:47. We were at the terminal at 03:57: 10 minutes, 3.3 miles. The price didn’t change from the booking, which wasn’t the case with our Uber from Luton. One odd detail: Uber Reserve asks for your flight, but its list only showed flights within the EU. Tirana wasn’t there.
For an early flight you can also pre-book a fixed-price Edinburgh Airport transfer with Welcome Pickups.
The bag drop was self-service, with about five people in line. Breakfast at Forth & Main at 05:13 was £30.95, and again no service charge.



All five planners that produced a new plan told us to take a taxi. Layla got the drive right (“10–12 minutes”). iMean allowed 20 to 30 minutes. Wanderlog left the door open to an “earliest practical tram/taxi combination”, which doesn’t exist at that hour.
The £150 lesson: Ryanair vs Wizz Air cabin bags
We flew to London with Wizz Air and home with Ryanair, both with priority boarding and a cabin bag. The same two suitcases went through Wizz Air without a question. At the Ryanair gate at 05:26, staff measured them. Each was 2 to 3 cm too thick. The fee was £75 per bag, £150 in total, and both went into the hold.
The difference is in the rules:
| Airline | Larger cabin bag with priority |
|---|---|
| Wizz Air | 55 × 40 × 23 cm |
| Ryanair | 55 × 40 × 20 cm |
Ryanair’s own fees page lists £70 to £75 for an oversized cabin bag at the gate. We paid £75 per bag.
Not one AI tool warned us. Neither the 11 planners in our London test nor the 7 in the mid-trip test mentioned cabin bag sizes. ChatGPT explained the 23 vs 20 cm difference on the plane, after we’d paid. If you change airlines mid-trip, measure your bags against the second airline’s rules.
Our real 3 days in Edinburgh itinerary with an 8-year-old
| Day | What we did | What worked |
|---|---|---|
| Wednesday (arrival) | LNER from King’s Cross, Airlink 100, walk to the hotel | The train: on time out, 15–20 minutes late in |
| Thursday | Family 3-Day tram ticket, Princes Street Gardens, the castle from outside, Royal Mile, Makars | Squirrels, and checking the tram website instead of the app |
| Friday | Old Town, The Meadows, hot chocolate, ramen | A slow day after a busy one |
| Saturday (Halloween) | Waterstones, picnic, National Gallery, golden hour, early night | Free activities, and a sunny day nobody forecast |
| Sunday | Uber at 03:47, 06:05 flight | 10 minutes to the terminal |
What it actually cost
Recorded on the spot, for two adults and an 8-year-old. Not included: hotel, flights and personal shopping.
| What | Amount |
|---|---|
| LNER, London to Edinburgh, family | £101.50 |
| Airlink 100, Waverley, group of three | £15.00 |
| Edinburgh Trams, Family 3-Day | £28.00 |
| Uber Reserve to the airport | £25.95 (+ £2 tip) |
| Makars Gourmet Mash Bar, dinner | £63.00 |
| Don@Tokyo, dinner | £49.80 and £44.20 |
| Fish & Frites van, lunch | £17.50 |
| Picnic from M&S | £25.00 |
| National Gallery | Free (locker £2) |
| Ryanair cabin bag fee at the gate | £150.00 |
In total we recorded £514.02 for October 29 to November 1, including the £150 bag fee. Fish and chips across the trip: £23.95 at a Westminster pub, £18.95 in Oxford, £17.50 from the van on the Royal Mile.
3 days in Edinburgh itinerary: what AI got wrong, in numbers
- 1 of 6 tools with a saved plan actually rewrote it for the new dates (Mindtrip), and it linked the castle to a pub.
- 2 of 7 said the plan was updated when it wasn’t (Wanderlog, Layla).
- 0 of 7 named the Family 3-Day tram ticket (£28).
- 0 of 7 warned that the castle sells out. 2 of 7 said to book ahead.
- 0 of 7 gave the Princes Street Gardens closing time. One said “Always open”.
- 1 of 7 mentioned Halloween.
- 1 of 7 promised an elevator at Camera Obscura (Layla). The official site: 98 steps, no elevator.
- 0 of 6 found Makars Mushroom Farm. 1 of 6 recommended a place that closed in 2021.
- 0 of 18 AI runs across both tests warned about the Ryanair cabin bag size.
Which AI tool to use for 3 days in Edinburgh
- On the ground: ChatGPT. It found the cheaper tram ticket, told us to book the castle and was the only one to mention Halloween.
- For a calendar you can open on the day: Mindtrip was the only one that really updated, but check every place it links to.
- Don’t trust “updated”: Wanderlog and Layla both said so, and the saved plans still showed the old trip.
- Check opening hours yourself: iMean’s “Always open” gardens close at 17:00, and its butterfly house closed in 2021.
→ Related: Mindtrip Review 2026: Honest Test on a Real Family Trip
FAQ
Is 3 days enough in Edinburgh with a kid?
For us, yes: one day for the Old Town and Princes Street Gardens, one slow day with The Meadows, and one for the National Gallery and a picnic. We saw the castle from outside, because it was sold out that day.
How do you get from Waverley station to Edinburgh Park?
We took the Airlink 100 bus with a group ticket for three (£15) and walked about 20 minutes with our bags. The tram is the easier option the rest of the time: from the Gyle Centre stop to Princes Street took about 24 minutes.
How much is the Edinburgh tram family ticket?
The Family 3-Day ticket was £28 on the tram website. The app only sold family day tickets at £13 each, and the ticket machine at our stop didn’t offer the 3-day option.
Is Edinburgh Castle sold out in October?
On Thursday, October 29, 2026, tickets for the day were sold out, and the sign at the gate recommended booking ahead.
Is Edinburgh good with kids in late October?
Yes, and Halloween week was a bonus: a free kids’ activity at Waterstones, costumes and the castle lit green and purple. Pack for rain, but we got a sunny Saturday. Princes Street Gardens close at 17:00.
Tested on the ground in Edinburgh, October 28 – November 1, 2026. The mid-trip AI test ran on October 25, 2026, and the hidden gems test on November 1. Free plans for every tool except TripBaddie, which ran on a paid plan the developer gave us free access to. No company paid to be included. All photos are originals from my phone.
Related:
→ AI Rome Itinerary Test: 9 Planners vs. a Real Family Trip
→ 5 Day London Itinerary: 11 AI Planners vs a Real Family Trip
→ ChatGPT Travel Planner 2026: Free Prompts That Actually Work
→ Mindtrip Review 2026: Honest Test on a Real Family Trip
→ Layla AI Review 2026: I Tested This AI Trip Planner on a Real Itinerary



